When an employee is injured at work, the California workers’ compensation system provides medical benefits to help with recovery and treatment. However, not all medical treatments requested by your doctor are automatically approved. In California, the Utilization Review (UR) process is used to determine whether the treatment prescribed for your work-related injury is medically necessary and eligible for workers’ compensation coverage.
The Utilization Review process can be confusing and frustrating for injured workers, especially when treatment is delayed or denied. Understanding how Utilization Review works and what you can do if your treatment is denied is critical to ensuring that you receive the medical care you need. In this guide, we’ll explain what Utilization Review is, how it impacts your workers’ compensation case, and what steps you can take if your treatment is denied or delayed.
1. What Is Utilization Review in California Workers’ Compensation?
Definition of Utilization Review (UR)
Utilization Review (UR) is a process used by workers’ compensation insurance companies to evaluate and approve or deny medical treatment requests made by doctors for injured workers. The goal of Utilization Review is to ensure that the treatment prescribed is medically necessary and complies with California’s medical treatment guidelines.
When you are injured at work, your treating physician will develop a treatment plan to help you recover from your injury. This treatment plan may include doctor visits, diagnostic tests, physical therapy, medications, or surgery. However, before these treatments can be provided, the insurance company must approve them through the Utilization Review process.
Why Utilization Review Exists
The primary purpose of Utilization Review is to prevent unnecessary or inappropriate medical treatments from being administered, which helps control the overall cost of workers’ compensation claims. By requiring medical treatments to be reviewed for necessity, insurance companies aim to ensure that only effective, evidence-based treatments are provided to injured workers.
While Utilization Review can help protect against excessive medical costs, it can also lead to delays or denials of legitimate treatments, leaving injured workers without the care they need.
2. How the Utilization Review Process Works
Step 1: Treatment Request from Your Doctor
The Utilization Review process begins when your treating physician submits a request for treatment to the workers’ compensation insurance company. This is known as a Request for Authorization (RFA) and includes details about the medical treatment being recommended, such as the type of treatment, the frequency, and the duration.
Step 2: Initial Review by the Insurance Company
Once the insurance company receives the RFA, they will conduct an initial review to determine whether the treatment meets California’s Medical Treatment Utilization Schedule (MTUS) guidelines. These guidelines outline the standard treatments and procedures that are considered medically necessary for specific types of injuries.
Step 3: Utilization Review Decision
There are three possible outcomes of a Utilization Review decision:
- Approval: If the insurance company agrees that the treatment is necessary and complies with MTUS guidelines, the treatment will be approved, and you can proceed with care.
- Modification: The insurance company may modify the treatment plan, approving part of the treatment but denying or altering other aspects of it.
- Denial: If the insurance company determines that the treatment is not medically necessary or does not comply with MTUS guidelines, the treatment request will be denied.
By law, the Utilization Review decision must be made within a specific time frame, usually within five business daysfor regular treatment requests and 72 hours for urgent treatment requests.
Step 4: Notification of Decision
Once the Utilization Review decision is made, the insurance company must notify both you and your treating physician of the outcome. If the treatment is approved, you can proceed with the prescribed care. However, if the treatment is denied or modified, you will receive a written explanation of the decision, including the medical rationale for the denial.
3. Common Reasons for Treatment Denials in Utilization Review
There are several reasons why a treatment request may be denied or modified during the Utilization Review process. Some of the most common reasons include:
1. The Treatment Does Not Follow MTUS Guidelines
California’s Medical Treatment Utilization Schedule (MTUS) outlines evidence-based treatment protocols for various types of injuries. If your doctor’s treatment plan does not align with these guidelines, the insurance company may deny or modify the request.
2. Insufficient Medical Documentation
If your treating physician does not provide enough medical evidence to support the treatment request, such as diagnostic test results, detailed medical records, or progress notes, the insurance company may deny the request due to a lack of supporting information.
3. The Treatment Is Considered Experimental or Unproven
If the requested treatment is considered experimental, alternative, or unproven by mainstream medical standards, it is likely to be denied during Utilization Review. Treatments that are not widely accepted or lack sufficient clinical evidence may not be approved for workers’ compensation coverage.
4. Previous Treatments Have Been Ineffective
If you’ve already undergone similar treatments without significant improvement, the insurance company may argue that continuing the same type of treatment is not medically necessary and deny the request.
4. What to Do If Your Treatment Is Denied in Utilization Review
If your treatment request is denied during the Utilization Review process, it’s important to take immediate action to protect your right to medical care. Here are the steps you should take if you receive a denial:
1. Review the Denial Notice
The denial notice you receive from the insurance company should include a detailed explanation of why your treatment was denied, including the medical evidence or guidelines used to support the decision. Carefully review this notice to understand the reasons behind the denial.
2. Talk to Your Doctor
If your treatment was denied, discuss the decision with your treating physician. Your doctor may be able to provide additional medical documentation or clarify the treatment request to support your case. In some cases, the denial may be based on a misunderstanding or lack of sufficient information, which your doctor can address.
3. Request an Independent Medical Review (IMR)
In California, if your treatment request is denied or modified through Utilization Review, you have the right to request an Independent Medical Review (IMR). An IMR is conducted by a third-party medical professional who will review your case and determine whether the denied treatment is medically necessary.
To request an IMR:
- You must submit your request within 30 days of receiving the Utilization Review denial notice.
- The request form should be included with the denial notice, or you can obtain it from the California Division of Workers’ Compensation (DWC) website.
- The IMR decision is generally issued within 30 days and is binding on both you and the insurance company.
4. Appeal the Decision
If the IMR also denies your treatment request, you may have further legal options. Working with an experienced workers’ compensation attorney can help you explore additional avenues for appealing the decision and ensuring that you receive the medical care you need.
5. How to Strengthen Your Medical Treatment Request
If you want to increase the chances of your treatment being approved during the Utilization Review process, here are some steps you and your doctor can take to strengthen your request:
1. Provide Detailed Medical Evidence
One of the most common reasons for treatment denials is insufficient medical documentation. Your doctor should include detailed medical records, test results, imaging studies (e.g., MRIs, X-rays), and progress notes that demonstrate the necessity of the treatment. The more evidence you can provide to support the need for treatment, the stronger your request will be.
2. Align Treatment with MTUS Guidelines
Ensure that your doctor’s treatment plan follows California’s Medical Treatment Utilization Schedule (MTUS)guidelines. These guidelines outline the most appropriate and effective treatments for common work-related injuries. If your doctor’s treatment deviates from these guidelines, the insurance company is more likely to deny the request.
3. Address Previous Treatments
If you have undergone previous treatments that were ineffective, your doctor should clearly explain why the new treatment is different and why it is more likely to help with your recovery. Addressing the reasons why prior treatments failed can help prevent the insurance company from denying your request based on past outcomes.
6. How Laguna Law Firm Can Help with Utilization Review Issues
Navigating the Utilization Review process can be complex and frustrating, especially when you are already dealing with a work-related injury. At Laguna Law Firm, our experienced workers’ compensation attorneys are here to help you through every step of the process and ensure that you receive the medical care you deserve.
Legal Support for Utilization Review Denials
At Laguna Law Firm, we provide comprehensive legal support for workers dealing with Utilization Review denials, including:
- Assisting with IMR requests: We can help you file an Independent Medical Review (IMR) to challenge the denial of your treatment request.
- Communicating with your doctor: We work with your treating physician to gather the necessary medical evidence and strengthen your treatment request.
- Appealing treatment denials: If your treatment is denied, we can represent you in appeals before the Workers’ Compensation Appeals Board (WCAB) to ensure that your medical needs are met.
- Pursuing alternative treatment options: We help you explore alternative treatment plans or approaches if the initial request is denied.
With offices in Mission Viejo, Los Angeles, West Covina, Corona, San Diego, Orange County, and Newport Beach, Laguna Law Firm is dedicated to helping injured workers across Southern California navigate the Utilization Review process and get the medical care they need.
Conclusion
The Utilization Review process is a critical part of California’s workers’ compensation system, designed to ensure that injured workers receive medically necessary care. However, it can also lead to delays and denials of legitimate treatments. If your treatment has been denied or modified through Utilization Review, it’s important to take immediate action to challenge the decision and protect your right to medical care.
At Laguna Law Firm, we are committed to helping injured workers navigate the complexities of Utilization Review and ensure that they receive the full range of workers’ compensation benefits. If you need help with a Utilization Review denial or any other aspect of your workers’ compensation case, contact us today for a free consultation.
Spanish 
English 