When recovering from a work-related injury, workers’ compensation benefits provide essential financial support, covering medical expenses and wage replacement during the recovery period. However, many injured workers are concerned about how returning to work—or seeking alternative employment—may affect their workers’ compensation benefits, especially if they are able to secure Substantial Gainful Employment (SGE).
Understanding how substantial gainful employment can impact your workers’ compensation benefits is important for ensuring that you maintain the financial support you need while balancing your ability to work. This article will explain what SGE is, how it affects workers’ compensation claims, and what you should know if you are returning to work or pursuing new employment after an injury.
1. What Is Substantial Gainful Employment (SGE)?
Definition of Substantial Gainful Employment (SGE)
Substantial Gainful Employment (SGE) refers to a level of work or earnings that provides an individual with a substantial income, typically above a certain threshold. In the context of workers’ compensation, SGE is often used to assess whether an injured worker is capable of earning a significant income despite their injury.
While there is no universal standard for what qualifies as SGE in workers’ compensation, the term is often used to describe employment that:
- Provides a meaningful income or wage.
- Reflects the worker’s ability to perform consistent job duties despite their injury.
- Does not require the worker to exceed their medical restrictions or limitations.
In some cases, SGE is determined by comparing the injured worker’s current earnings to their pre-injury wage. If an injured worker is able to secure employment with wages close to or above their pre-injury earnings, they may be considered to have reached SGE, which can affect their eligibility for certain workers’ compensation benefits.
SGE in Workers’ Compensation vs. Social Security Disability
It’s important to distinguish between the use of SGE in workers’ compensation and Social Security Disability Insurance (SSDI) claims. While SGE is used in SSDI to determine eligibility for disability benefits, it is also relevant in workers’ compensation when assessing whether an injured worker can return to work in a meaningful capacity and how this return impacts wage replacement benefits.
2. How SGE Impacts Workers’ Compensation Benefits
When an injured worker returns to substantial gainful employment, their workers’ compensation benefits may be affected, particularly in cases involving wage replacement benefits, such as Temporary Disability (TD) or Permanent Disability (PD) benefits. Here’s how SGE can impact different aspects of your workers’ compensation claim:
1. Temporary Disability Benefits
Temporary Disability (TD) benefits are awarded to injured workers who are temporarily unable to work due to a work-related injury. TD benefits are calculated based on the worker’s average weekly wage and are meant to replace lost wages during the recovery period. However, if an injured worker is able to return to work at a level that qualifies as SGE, their eligibility for TD benefits may be affected.
Temporary Total Disability (TTD) and SGE
Workers receiving Temporary Total Disability (TTD) benefits are considered completely unable to work. If you return to substantial gainful employment, your TTD benefits will likely be terminated, as the fact that you are earning a meaningful income indicates that you are no longer totally disabled.
Temporary Partial Disability (TPD) and SGE
For workers receiving Temporary Partial Disability (TPD) benefits, the situation is more nuanced. TPD benefits are provided when an injured worker is able to return to work in a limited capacity but cannot earn their full pre-injury wages. If your new earnings qualify as SGE but are still below your pre-injury wage, your TPD benefits may be reduced but not eliminated entirely. TPD benefits typically cover the difference between your pre-injury wage and your current earnings.
2. Permanent Disability Benefits
Permanent Disability (PD) benefits compensate injured workers for the long-term impact of their injury on their earning capacity. PD benefits are based on a permanent disability rating, which reflects the severity of the worker’s impairment. Returning to substantial gainful employment may affect your PD benefits depending on the nature of your injury and your disability rating.
Permanent Partial Disability (PPD) and SGE
If you have been assigned a Permanent Partial Disability (PPD) rating and are able to return to substantial gainful employment, your PD benefits may be adjusted to reflect your new earning capacity. While PPD benefits are awarded based on your long-term impairment, they can be impacted by your ability to secure meaningful employment. In some cases, returning to SGE may result in a reduction or termination of your PPD benefits.
Permanent Total Disability (PTD) and SGE
For workers with a Permanent Total Disability (PTD) rating, returning to SGE may be more difficult. PTD benefits are awarded to workers who are deemed unable to perform any gainful employment due to the severity of their injury. If you are receiving PTD benefits but are able to secure substantial gainful employment, your PTD benefits may be discontinued, as the ability to work may indicate that you are no longer totally disabled.
3. Returning to Work With Work Restrictions and SGE
Many injured workers return to work with specific medical restrictions that limit their ability to perform certain tasks. If your employer offers you a modified or light-duty position that accommodates your medical restrictions, this may qualify as SGE if it provides a substantial income and allows you to maintain consistent employment.
Modified or Light-Duty Assignments
Returning to a modified or light-duty assignment means you are working within the limitations set by your treating physician. For example, you may be restricted from lifting heavy objects, standing for long periods, or performing repetitive motions. If you can perform these modified tasks while earning a substantial income, your workers’ compensation benefits may be affected based on your new earning capacity.
Impact on Wage Replacement Benefits
If your modified or light-duty job qualifies as SGE, your temporary or permanent disability benefits may be reduced or eliminated, depending on how close your current earnings are to your pre-injury wage. However, if you are earning less than your pre-injury wage, you may still be eligible for partial benefits to cover the wage gap.
4. Substantial Gainful Employment and Vocational Rehabilitation
For injured workers who are unable to return to their previous job due to permanent disabilities, vocational rehabilitation can be an important tool in finding substantial gainful employment. In California, the workers’ compensation system offers Supplemental Job Displacement Benefits (SJDB) to help workers retrain and acquire new skills that can lead to SGE.
Supplemental Job Displacement Benefits (SJDB)
If your employer cannot accommodate your work restrictions and you cannot return to your pre-injury position, you may be eligible for SJDB, which provides a voucher for job retraining or skill development. These vouchers can be used for education or training programs that prepare you for new job opportunities, potentially leading to substantial gainful employment in a different field.
SJDB benefits are available to injured workers who have a permanent partial disability and cannot return to their previous job. By using the voucher to retrain or gain new qualifications, you can increase your chances of securing SGE, which may impact your workers’ compensation benefits but improve your long-term earning potential.
5. Navigating the Transition to Substantial Gainful Employment
Returning to work after a work-related injury can be a major milestone, but it’s important to understand how this transition will affect your workers’ compensation benefits. Here are some key steps to take when navigating the shift to SGE:
1. Consult With Your Doctor About Work Restrictions
Before returning to work, consult with your treating physician to ensure that any job offer or employment opportunity aligns with your medical restrictions. Working outside of your restrictions can aggravate your injury and jeopardize your recovery.
2. Review Your Earning Capacity
If you are able to secure substantial gainful employment, review your current earnings compared to your pre-injury wage. This comparison will help you understand how your wage replacement benefits, such as TPD or PPD, may be adjusted based on your new earning capacity.
3. Communicate With Your Employer and Insurance Company
Keep your employer and the workers’ compensation insurance company informed about your return to work and your new earnings. Transparency about your work status and income is essential for ensuring that your benefits are calculated accurately and adjusted appropriately.
4. Consult a Workers’ Compensation Attorney
If you are unsure about how SGE will impact your workers’ compensation benefits or if you believe your benefits are being unfairly reduced, consult with an experienced workers’ compensation attorney. An attorney can help you navigate the complexities of returning to work, advocate for your rights, and ensure that your benefits are properly adjusted.
How Laguna Law Firm Can Help With Substantial Gainful Employment and Workers’ Compensation Claims
At Laguna Law Firm, we understand the challenges injured workers face when transitioning back to work and how substantial gainful employment can impact workers’ compensation benefits. Our experienced workers’ compensation attorneys provide guidance, support, and representation to ensure that you receive the maximum benefits while balancing your return to work.
Comprehensive Legal Support for Workers Returning to SGE
Our team offers comprehensive legal assistance, including:
- Evaluating your work restrictions: We help you assess your work restrictions and ensure that any job offer or return to work aligns with your medical limitations.
- Navigating benefit adjustments: We guide you through the process of adjusting your temporary or permanent disability benefits based on your new earning capacity.
- Advocating for vocational rehabilitation: If you cannot return to your previous role, we help you secure Supplemental Job Displacement Benefits to support your retraining and transition to substantial gainful employment.
With offices in Mission Viejo, Los Angeles, West Covina, Corona, San Diego, Orange County, and Newport Beach, Laguna Law Firm is dedicated to helping injured workers across Southern California secure the benefits they deserve while returning to meaningful employment.
Conclusion
Substantial gainful employment can significantly impact your workers’ compensation benefits, particularly when it comes to wage replacement and disability compensation. By understanding how your return to work affects your benefits and consulting with an experienced workers’ compensation attorney, you can navigate the transition smoothly and protect your financial stability.
If you’re returning to work and are concerned about how substantial gainful employment will affect your workers’ compensation benefits, Laguna Law Firm is here to help. Contact us today for a free consultation, and let us help you protect your rights and maximize your benefits.
Spanish 
English 